Islam Makhachev has the opportunity to surpass his mentor Khabib Nurmagomedov‘s record of three consecutive lightweight title defenses by securing a fourth against Arman Tsarukyan, potentially sparking debates about his standing as one of the greatest lightweights in MMA history despite having one loss on his record.
Islam Makhachev is poised to make history this Saturday if he triumphs over Arman Tsarukyan in the UFC 311 main event. A victory would mark his fourth consecutive title defense at 155 pounds, surpassing the record held by his mentor, Khabib Nurmagomedov. Khabib retired with three straight defenses and an unblemished 29-0 record, cementing his legacy as perhaps the greatest lightweight in MMA.
Yet, if Makhachev breaks this record, does he dethrone “The Eagle” as the best lightweight ever? It’s a question that sparks debate among fans, fighters, and media alike. Matt Brown weighed in on The Fighter vs. The Writer podcast, noting that greatness is often subjective. Jon Jones, for instance, is widely considered the greatest despite controversies surrounding steroid use.
Brown suggests that while Makhachev’s lone loss might be a blemish compared to Nurmagomedov’s perfect record, it doesn’t necessarily detract from his overall achievements. Many argue that losses can reflect the level of competition and resilience a fighter faces. In boxing, legends like Muhammad Ali faced defeats yet are still hailed as all-time greats.
Brown argues that losses don’t diminish a fighter’s legacy; they show adversity. If Khabib had faced tougher opponents early on, he might have tasted defeat too. When fighting at the top level, title defenses become crucial in determining greatness. Makhachev deserves to be part of that conversation.
Over time, most fighters experience defeat. Makhachev’s came early in his career, while Khabib retired undefeated. What could have happened if Khabib continued fighting? It’s anyone’s guess. Brown believes everyone has weaknesses and will eventually lose if they fight long enough.
Jon Jones is praised for his accomplishments but has faced contentious decisions. Losses aren’t the sole factor in discrediting someone from being considered the greatest of all time. For Makhachev, another title defense against a top contender like Tsarukyan would solidify his standing.
A dominant win over Tsarukyan could further elevate Makhachev’s status alongside Nurmagomedov. Brown feels any win should suffice to earn him recognition among the greats. If Makhachev wins this fight, he’s at the top of the list for Brown.
The debate continues: Who’s greater—Islam or Khabib? Or maybe B.J.? It’s all about those nitty-gritty details now. Catch new episodes of The Fighter vs. The Writer every Tuesday on Apple Podcasts, Google Podcasts, Spotify, and iHeartRadio!